Sister Celluloid

Where old movies go to live

JOURNEY’S END: A War Film Made by Those Who Lived It

The most powerful war movie I ever saw was the least bloody—perhaps because the writer and director had barely escaped the battlefield themselves.

After penning a few drawing-room dramas during the 1920s, playwright R.C. Sherriff decided it was finally time to face down his memories of The Great War. He’d just about made it home in one piece after being wounded on the Western Front, and was awarded the Military Cross—but the images that kept percolating in his mind were of other things entirely. The everyday struggles. Long stretches of boredom edged with constant, simmering fear. Foul smells, lousy food, muddy trenches and wet feet. Damp, cramped dugouts. And friends. Always friends. The ones who listened, who understood, who never judged, who kept you from falling apart.

sis-sherriff sis-sherriff-1

Sherriff poured all this and more into his play Journey’s End.

And he found the perfect director in James Whale. A former set designer with a great eye for mood and detail, Whale had something even more important going for him: He understood exactly what Sherriff  was talking about. Whale had also fought on the Western Front, and had been captured and held prisoner for almost a year and a half.

But while Sherriff and Whale were ready to revist their war years with this powerful story, producers backed away in droves. “Every management in London had turned the play down,” Sherriff recalled later. “They said people didn’t want war plays. They asked, how can I put on a play with no leading lady?” (No Leading Lady later became the title of his autobiography.)

sis-journeysend-3 sis-journeysend-4

In desperation, the playwright sent a copy of Journey’s End to George Bernard Shaw, asking for his endorsement. Shaw called the play “a useful corrective to the romantic concept of war” and said that as “a ‘slice of life’—horribly abnormal life—it should be produced by all means.” Soon after, in late 1928, Sherriff secured a small London theatre for a showcase, with 21-year-old Laurence Olivier in the lead role of Captain Denis Stanhope. But by the time the play moved up to the West End the following year, Olivier was committed elsewhere.

Sherriff had noticed a young actor named Colin Clive in a variety of smaller stage roles which, in his hands, didn’t seem small at all. He thought Clive had exactly the kind of edgy, brittle intensity needed to capture Stanhope in all his anguish. He was right.

sis-journeysend-5 colin-portrait20

Journey’s End proved to be such a hit that in less than a year, Hollywood came calling for the film rights. Whale signed with Universal to direct the project, but the studio already had its own stable of stars and wasn’t much interested in Clive, despite his stellar stage notices. And Clive, for his part, was more than happy to stay on the London stage. After a bit of wrangling, the determined director finally sold each side to the other, and Clive sailed for the States.

In his autobiography, Flashback, producer George Pearson recalls that Clive arrived in New York on Thanksgiving Day 1929—and had just 25 minutes to get from the dock to the train station to catch the Twentieth Century Limited to Los Angeles. He then picks up the story in Hollywood: “Colin’s entry on that set, as Stanhope, seemed, in some miraculous way, to turn make-believe into sudden stark reality. Even the stagehands stopped to look: captured, curious, puzzled.”

Journey's End sis-journeysend

Journey’s End takes place almost entirely in a dugout in St, Quentin, France in March 1918, on the eve of what threatens to be an especially bloody battle. The war may be just months from ending, but the fighting is no less ferocious.

Sherriff often said he never set out to make an anti-war story. But he couldn’t have made a more powerful one if he’d tried. Thanks also to Whale’s sensitive, intimate direction, you feel as if you’re walled in with these men and their fears, their memories, their hopes, and their confusion and anger about why they’re in this hellhole in the first place. You flinch every time you hear a shell explode outside, as the sudden shock punctuates the joking, the drinking, the sharing of stories and photographs, the routines that keep them sane.

You worry yourself sick about the people you meet here: young 2nd Lieutenant Raleigh (David Manners), eager to make good and too new to it all, at least at first, to fully grasp the horror of what he’s been plunged into. Lieutenant Osborne (Ian McLaren), the father figure of this ill-starred family, whom everyone calls Uncle, the man you’d want by your side in a foxhole and even more so if you were forced to climb out of it. And of course Captain Stanhope, breaking under the strain and misery of battle, turning more and more to drink to get him through days that had stretched into years. Deeply ashamed, he’s terrified his men will see his fear—and how he uses liquor to dull the edges of it—and turn away from him in disgust.

colin-journeysend6-nowriting colin-journeysend-108

How easy it would be to overplay the role of the tortured captain, to milk every ounce of pathos out of it. But Colin Clive is completely natural. There’s nothing “actor-y” about him. He is Stanhope. Everything that’s noble and flawed and terrified and brave about the man is completely laid bare, without technique or artifice. He’s so open, so real, that you feel like you’re intruding on his private misery. Like you’re peering at him through a keyhole or a cracked-open door.

In one scene, when he crumples to the floor in grief, I was actually scared he’d hurt himself. Because it was a real fall. He doesn’t fling himself down dramatically; he collapses under the weight of his pain. And he sobs the way real people do, not the way movie people do.

Later on, when Raleigh is carried in, grievously wounded, he tenderly cradles his head as he eases him onto a cot. As Raleigh turns toward him, desperate for some sign of hope or encouragement, Stanhope’s face softens from dread to reassurance. Soon after, it floods with anguish and sheer disgust at the sickening waste of it all. As the film closes, he climbs the steps of the dugout to face his worst fear, and the fragile, makeshift hut—now under mortar fire—collapses behind him.

colin-journeysend11

When shooting wrapped on Journey’s End shortly after Christmas 1929, Clive sailed home to England to resume his stage career, little realizing he’d soon be called back to take on the part he’s most famous for: the title role in Whale’s Frankenstein.

Though they share a star and a director, the two films could not be further apart. In fact, there’s a scene in Journey’s End that’s almost the mirror opposite of the famous soliloquy in Frankenstein, when Henry asks, “Have you never wanted to look beyond the clouds and the stars, or to know what causes the trees to bud, or what changes the darkness into light…”

Stanhope is talking to Osborne about how imagination can be a curse, and how he envies the lack of it in the camp’s cook, Mason: “I suppose if Mason were to look up at that sky at night, he’d just see the stars. He wouldn’t see the space beyond the stars that makes you sick and giddy and want to cling on to something…”

Clive beautifully captures a dreamer’s hope in one, and a soldier’s terror in the other. He made only 18 films, but that slender volume of work was enough to prove he could do just about anything.

colin-journey-woman1 colin-frankenstein68

As for Whale and Sherriff, they’d team up twice more—for One More River (also with Clive, as a villainous husband) and for the ill-fated film version of Erich Maria Remarque’s anti-war novel The Road Back, which Universal cravenly cut to ribbons to appease the Nazi regime, thereby retaining access to the German film market (the whole sordid story on that is here).

But Journey’s End remains their deeply personal masterpiece.

Where To Find It: Because the film’s rights issues are somehwat in limbo, a complete but grainy print is still up on YouTube. It’s iffy-looking at best, but still worth a look. The British Film Institute apparently has a pristine negative of the film, but no print from it has ever been released.

For more on the life and work of the much-undersung James Whale, turn to James Curtis’s terrific biography, James Whale: A New World of Gods and Monsters.

16 Comments

  1. I’ve never even heard of this movie, but thanks to your excellent write-up, I now want to check it out. Is it out on DVD?

    • Thank you so much for your kind words, Sean! It isn’t on DVD — it’s ensnared in all kinds of rights issues. But there’s now interest in making another film of it, which means someone might be motivated to work out the rights issues sooner rather than later.

      In the meantime, the grainy version of the film is still up on YouTube. But there’s not a direct link to it any more. Do a search for “Journey’s End 1930” and the first result will be “Pre-Code Full Length Movies,” posted by the user cantstopthemovies. Then scroll down the list of movies on the right and click Journey’s End. As if that weren’t complicated enough, sometimes that internal link works, and sometimes it doesn’t, and you need to fiddle with it a bit. But it’s well worth it, even for an iffy print.

  2. I’d always felt that this film was considerably more poignant than other war films, clearly it’s because the original writers were writing ‘from life’. It’s such a shame it’s not more widely available (my dad has a recorded-from-the-TV copy) and I like the sound of a re-make but only if it’s not Hollywood-ised and handled with the same subtlety and consideration. Nice review!

  3. Thanks for this heartfelt review–I don’t think I’ve heard of this one before. It makes sense that such a powerful war movie would come from people who had actually lived through the war–a way of dealing with painful memories and spreading the truth of what really happened, as you addressed in the beginning.

    • Thank you so much, Lea! And yes, “heartfelt” definitely describes it… I love both the film and Colin Clive, and will even be adding a section to the website about him and his work! If you watch the movie on YT, I would love to know what you think of it…

      • Definitely, will be checking it out!

  4. Great post! As a kid, I had the Frankenstein poster etched in my brain: About James whale, it said, “from the genius who brought you Journey’s End and Waterloo Bridge.” Now I’m finally inspired to watch them!

  5. Thank you for introducing me to “Journey’s End”.

  6. This sounds like an amazing film, with the kind of subtle, everyday details and reflections that make Tim O’Brien’s work so moving. I’ll check it out.

  7. Fascinating stuff, I read a piece a little while ago that suggested war films today are less convincing than those from, say, the 50s because many of the star from back then had seen active service. I’d guess that James Whale’s (painful) experience would also have added a lot to Journey’s End.

    By the way, not sure if you’ve seen Gods and Monsters (if not, it’s well worth a look) but Journey’s End and The Road Back get mentions and Whale’s wartime experiences are central to the story.

  8. classicfilmtvcafe

    An excellent history and examination of a film I haven’t much too long. I just did some research on R.C. Sherriff for a film review (DRACULA’S DAUGHTER) and was amazed to learn of his screenwriting work. Not only did he write some of the best-known classics from the 1930s and 1940s, but he also apparently “cleaned up” many other scripts. Have you seen ACES HIGH, the 1976 remake of JOURNEY’S END with Malcolm McDowell? I have not, but cannot imagine it capturing the subtle power of the original screen version.

    • Thank you for your kind words, Rick!! I haven’t seen the Mslcolm McDowell version but like you I doubt it could live up to the incredible 1930 version. I have heard talk of another remake, possibly with Benedict Cumberbatch, and while I like him, I’m leery of that too!! 🙂

  9. This sounds like a powerful film. Thanks for the info on R.C. Sherriff – and THANK YOU for embedding the video in your post. I shall bookmark for a later viewing. 🙂

    • Ruth, please tell me what you think of it when you have a chance to watch! And yes, I always try to embed films, clips or links when available!!

  10. Thank You, Friend. Your commentary should be required reading, on both the Film AND the Play.

Trackbacks

  1. The Stage to Screen Blogathon | The Rosebud Cinema

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: